Main section
-
Top story
Interpal accuses Panorama of lack of balance
DATELINE: 1/8/06
The Chairman of Trustees of British charity Interpal has called the BBC Panorama programme Faith, hate and charity, transmitted on Sunday 30 July, a "wholly unbalanced and incomplete picture". Speaking after viewing the programme, Ibrahim Hewitt called into question the BBC's decision to broadcast this edition of the supposed flagship of the corporation's current affairs output on the day that Israeli missiles killed 54 civilians - most of them children - in Qana and Israel was under increasing pressure over its military action in Lebanon and the Gaza Strip.
"We are extremely concerned that the Panorama production team appears to have gone out with a pre-set thesis and made a programme to suit a particular political agenda," said Mr. Hewitt. "There is a severe imbalance inherent in the content that gives the lie to the claim that this is responsible investigative journalism. In giving viewers an incomplete narrative, they have been left with a distorted picture of the truth, without which it is impossible to reach balanced and reasoned conclusions."
By way of illustration, Mr. Hewitt drew attention to the remarks of the spokesman from the US Treasury, interviewed by reporter John Ware, who expressed his purported "bewilderment" at the Charity Commission's 2003 decision to unfreeze Interpal's accounts in the wake of the Bush administration's designation of Interpal as a "terrorist entity". What the programme completely failed to point out, however, was that the Charity Commission did at the time give the US Treasury ample opportunity to provide evidence for its decision to brand Interpal as a "terrorist entity", but the US authorities were unable and unwilling to do so.
Mr. Hewitt also pointed out that the Trustees did not decline to be interviewed for the programme, as alleged by John Ware. One of the Trustees gave many hours of his time to Mr. Ware's questioning off-camera, but the BBC refused to agree to Interpal's request that any such interview should be shown in full and live, or recorded as live, and not subject to what the Trustees feared would be selective and unbalanced editing. These fears arose out of a similarly unbalanced and controversial edition of Panorama concerning the Muslim Council of Britain, which was broadcast last year and was produced by the same BBC team, giving rise to fears throughout the Muslim community as to the unfair and unrepresentative manner in which these programmes are researched and reported. Last night's broadcast demonstrated that these fears remain well-founded.
In closing, Mr. Hewitt said, "All charities working in war zones face attempts to drag them into the political arena, and Interpal is no exception. This is not the first time that we have been accused of unlawful activity and it will probably not be the last, and the allegations contained in the Panorama programme are nothing new. Only last year, the Trustees of Interpal won an out-of-court libel settlement from the Board of Deputies of British Jews, despite the Board of Deputies committing vast financial resources to the litigation and garnering support from Israel and the USA.
Accusations such as those contained in the Panorama programme should not divert us from the very real humanitarian needs of Palestinians and our entirely lawful efforts to alleviate their suffering. As we have made clear repeatedly, Interpal is politically neutral in the collection and distribution of funds as is required by Charity Commission guidelines governing the operation of charities in this country. In addition, as a charity committed to relieving hardship and suffering, we have never supported ‑ and will never support - any terrorism or illegal activities. We will continue to cooperate fully with the UK authorities ‑ including the Charity Commission ‑ in any enquiries they may wish to raise with us and to grant them unfettered access to our records, as we have always done to-date."
This matter is now in the hands of Interpal's legal advisers, Carter-Ruck.
Last modified: Wednesday, August 2, 2006
PCC is 'farcical', says ex-director of public prosecutions
EFJ conference calls on EU to act on media and journalism crisis
CPBF condemns temporary shutdown for WikiLeaks
CWU blasts damaging Tory plans on broadband
BBC research into lesbian, gay and bisexual portrayal 'welcomed'
Exposed - China's secret bans on media reporting
Libel laws group announced
PCC Governance Review
Court tells Sky to cut ITV stake
As Haiti disaster unfolds , IFJ plans aid for victims in media and journalism
Alastair Campbell's 'unprecedented' role in preparing dossier on Iraq's weapons of mass destruction
IFJ mourns latest media death in Afghanistan
2009 leaves one of worst records for targeted killings of journalists
Media firms bid for ITV bulletins
Government happy for lobbyists to stay in the shadows
Action on product placement
Police cautious over photo curbs
Copenhagen police accused of violating human rights
Scottish parliament inquiry into local newspaper decline
Project Censored - the top twenty five stories
Police U-turn on photographers and anti-terror laws
Lobby Planet Paris just published!
Google to limit free news access
Welcome for working group on libel reform
Costs blow in protection of sources case
Superdrug strikers march back to work
Wanted - your views on the PCC
Straw to look at libel law reform
IFJ to investigate role of UK press complaints body in telephone tapping controversy
Campaigning organisation to continue fight for BBC
-
Notices
Events & Announcements
Nick Davies, Bad News: Benn Journalism Lecture 2009
DATELINE: 1/12/09Commercial imperatives are elbowing out truth in the UK media, says Nick Davies who reviewed media lies and the state of journalism in Britain today in the fourth Benn Lecture at Bristol Arnolfini Arts Centre on 26 November.
Bad News, 2009 Benn Lecture - mp3 12M
-
Previous stories
News
Free Press index launched
Without Comment
How the US media destroy democracy
John Pilger
It’s Not Cricket
Without Comment
Without Comment
Digital TV and state abuse of power
Beyond TV: everything for the video activist
Without Comment
In the USA today
Spies like us....
Sir Frank Rogers: Obituary
Not so public launch
Indymedia seizure explained - in part
NUJ's new place in the Sun
Without Comment: FA hires from DCMS
Jim’s Journal
Without Comment
Without Comment
Without Comment
Read this...
The G8 Alternatives Summit spotlights the media
Transport police seize Bristol Indymedia server
Without Comment
News for Sale: Information in the Age of Market-Driven Journalism
CPBF/NUJ/BECTU Conference: 'The future of the BBC and public service broadcasting'
Making the important interesting: Grade speaks!
2004 - A dark and deadly year for the media
Green Paper delayed - or is it?