Main section
-
Top story
Puttnam on the PCC: 'I'd give it a year'
Josh Halliday guardian.co.uk
DATELINE: 6/7/10
Lord Puttnam said politicians had been 'too compliant for too long' in their dealings with the media. The Press Complaints Commission should be scrapped if newspapers do not "improve their behaviour within a year", Lord Puttnam said last night (29 June). In a terse question-and-answer session after a lecture to an invited audience of politically engaged teenagers, the Labour peer said politicians had been "too compliant for too long" in dealing with the media.
In response to a question about whether the PCC was redundant, Puttnam said he thought that the system of press self regulation should be scrapped if newspapers do not "improve their behaviour within a year". "I'd give it a year," he added.
Puttnam said that the PCC in its current form was a "snakepit", which has proved "impossible" to change. He added that fellow peer Baroness Peta Buscombe had taken up the position of chair of the PCC with the intention of reducing the number of deviations from its code of conduct, but that under the current setup there was a reluctance to change.When contacted today by MediaGuardian.co.uk to expand on his comments last night, Puttnam replied: "I believe the PCC does a pretty good job of handling individual complaints from those who feel themselves to have been in some way traduced.
"What they cannot do is prevent the slow reduction of politics to a form of gruesome spectator sport. Nor can they ensure the general representation of young people is more representative of reality. "I believe they should be given a year to address these issues and if they find it impossible then the type of regulation Ofcom imposes on television would seem to become appropriate, and probably inevitable. The national press at that point will only have themselves to blame. "As to Baroness Buscombe, she is a very decent woman who I believe sincerely understands these issues but has not been given the firepower to do very much about changing what is an ingrained bullying attitude on the part of those who ultimately pay her salary."During last night's talk, Puttnam stressed that politicians had to be brave and face up to the need for a drastic change in the regulation of newspapers. An eagerness to stay on-side with the press had left parliament and the media in "a battleground of the lowest common denominator", he told the gathering, adding that he was in no doubt that this relationship had influenced tough policy decisions.
Earlier, in his lecture at the House of Lords, he said: "What we are dealing with here are parallel inadequacies, those of what, for convenience, I'll call 'parliament', and those of an ever more competitive communications industry. "Between them they have managed to construct a battlefield upon which the big losers are truth, illumination and common sense; the very things we most need if we are to understand and make sense of this increasingly dangerous and complex world of ours. "For their part politicians and the civil servants who support them feel trapped in the malevolent glare of a media culture whose primary purpose is to undermine rather than underpin public confidence. The national – or is it international – obsession with the trivial is increasingly making the intelligent exercise of public life all but impossible."
Puttnam, 69, who is deputy chairman of Channel 4 and a former chief executive of Columbia Pictures, continued: "If David Cameron is remotely serious about wanting to herald in a new type of politics, he will have to do a lot better than inviting Rupert Murdoch to see him as one of the first acts of his premiership, and allowing him to enter number 10 by the back stairs. "As the former cabinet minister John Biffen once memorably said: 'Whenever the prime minister of the day gets together in secret conclave with a powerful media owner, you can be very sure that democracy is not being well served'. The Labour peer also pointed to former prime ministers Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, saying they too were guilty of courting the press.
Stephen Abellof the PCC responded: "I have to say that I find Lord Puttnam's comments as odd as they are unhelpful. He has made two complaints to the PCC (including one recently), both of which were resolved to his express satisfaction. "In a letter to the PCC, he said the following: 'I would also like to take the opportunity to say how very grateful I am for both the speed and quality of the service I received from the PCC. I had no reason to expect anything less, but I assure you it's very much appreciated.'" Abell added: "His reported comments are also out of step with public opinion. Recent polling research showed that only 14% of a representative sample thought that the PCC was ineffective. Indeed 75% of those who expressed an opinion thought that the PCC was either effective or very effective.
"The PCC is interested, and effective, in protecting the legitimate privacy rights of individuals. Indeed only two weeks ago Baroness Buscombe argued successfully at the Oxford Union in support of the notion public figures do have a right to a private life. The PCC rigorously requires that newspapers and magazines must justify all reporting of the private lives of public figures on public interest grounds.
"The current independent review of the PCC's governance demonstrates our commitment to ongoing improvement. The review (which is shortly to publish its report) was initiated by Baroness Buscombe shortly after her appointment to 'make sure we have taken account of good practice elsewhere and wider public expectations'."Stephen Abell, director of the Press Complaints Commission, responded to Lord Puttnam's call to scrap the PCC if newspapers do not "improve their behaviour within a year" in an article for Index on Censorship. To read the full article go to: indexoncensorship.org
Main article: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jun/30/scrap-pcc-says-lord-puttnam
Last modified: Tuesday, July 6, 2010
Your comments:
» Click here to add your comment.
Comments will be subject to approval and should not be defamatory, obscene, racist, in breach of copyright, or contrary to law. The CPBF is not reponsible for any views expressed here.
Previous press complaints commission stories
IFJ report on hacking row exposes weakness of UK Press Complaints Commission:
NoW accused of tapping 'amnesia'
Stephen Gately the CPBF and the PPC
Gately column complaint rejected
PCC is 'farcical', says ex-director of public prosecutions
PCC Governance Review
Wanted - your views on the PCC
IFJ to investigate role of UK press complaints body in telephone tapping controversy
MPs express anger at PCC phone hacking 'whitewash'
Making the PPC accountable - sign up now
PCC to examine Mail Gately column
PCC to investigate itself
New attempt to reform PCC
Fewer Complaints and Greater Complacency
Submission to DCMS on press regulation
Press Complaints Commission widens its remit
Frankenstein Unbound?
CPBF writes to PCC on editors' code of conduct
A Pathetic Judgement
Slow and shoddy should be PCC slogan
PCC rejects CPBF Express complaint
CPBF launches complaint against Express
CPBF calls on PCC to open the books
-
Notices
Events & Announcements
Fringe meeting at the TUC
DATELINE: 26/8/10Tuesday 14 September 6.00pm – 8.00pm Mayor’s Parlour, Manchester Town Hall, M2 5DB
‘Media for All – the Democratic Challenge’.
An open event hosted by Making Good Society and the Campaign for Press and Broadcasting Freedom (CPBF), supported by the Carnegie UK Trust.
DOWNLOAD FREEPRESS NOW
DATELINE: 26/3/10
Download PDFs of Freepress here.
MEDIA FOR ALL CONFERENCE 09
DATELINE: 26/3/10
Media for All Conference 09
Conference Papers
-
Previous stories
Press Complaints Commission
IFJ report on hacking row exposes weakness of UK Press Complaints Commission:
NoW accused of tapping 'amnesia'
Stephen Gately the CPBF and the PPC
Gately column complaint rejected
PCC is 'farcical', says ex-director of public prosecutions
PCC Governance Review
Wanted - your views on the PCC
IFJ to investigate role of UK press complaints body in telephone tapping controversy
MPs express anger at PCC phone hacking 'whitewash'
Making the PPC accountable - sign up now
PCC to examine Mail Gately column
PCC to investigate itself
New attempt to reform PCC
Fewer Complaints and Greater Complacency
Submission to DCMS on press regulation
Press Complaints Commission widens its remit
Frankenstein Unbound?
CPBF writes to PCC on editors' code of conduct
A Pathetic Judgement
Slow and shoddy should be PCC slogan
PCC rejects CPBF Express complaint
CPBF launches complaint against Express
CPBF calls on PCC to open the books